AI governance software buyer’s guide: 6 criteria to test

Written by
Lucia Giles
Sr. Content Marketing Manager
Reviewed by
Vicki Robertson

Accelerating security solutions for small businesses 
‍

Tagore offers strategic services to small businesses. 

A partnership that can scale 
‍

Tagore prioritized finding a managed compliance partner with an established product, dedicated support team, and rapid release rate.

Standing out from competitors
‍

Tagore's partnership with Vanta enhances its strategic focus and deepens client value, creating differentiation in a competitive market.

Your teams adopted AI agents faster than anyone could track, and now, you are accountable for what those tools reach. Your company kept up with the pace of innovation, but the tradeoff is figuring out how to build an AI governance program. The more you look into it, however, the more complex it seems: There are the AI agents to track, but building a true AI governance includes covering the non-agent side, too. 

‍

An AI governance program requires numerous components, including:

‍

  • Inventory
  • Risk assessments
  • Controls
  • Guardrails
  • Evidence collection

‍

It’s a big task, and it’s a good instinct to find software and one or more vendors to support the work. Different vendors will offer tools to support different components or combinations of components. The problem is that every solution takes a different approach. If you’re trying to figure out what AI governance is, it can be tricky because the category is still forming, meaning a feature list can’t tell you much.

‍

Instead, evaluate vendors against what you have to govern, layer by layer in the same order a program gets built. That order runs objectives, inventory, risk, controls, and compliance which is the same sequence a foundational AI governance program is rooted in. Keep in mind how AI governance differs from AI compliance and AI security. 

‍

Six criteria at a glance

This evaluation approach comes from Vanta's own GRC engineering practice, and with it, you can evaluate a vendor’s offering in the order a program is actually built.

‍

Criterion What to ask the vendor What to see in the demo and what to look out for
1. Accounts for your objectives How do you record a use case and tie it to AI assets? A dedicated place for documenting use cases for AI. Flexibility for linking use cases to AI assets (products, MCP servers, etc.) in a one-to-many way. An ability to assign use cases to owners. Watch out for offerings that don’t natively ways to create, track, assign, review, and document approval/rejection decisions about AI use cases.
2. Builds a real inventory Show me the listing of AI products, agents, models, and MCP servers Products, agents, the models behind them, the systems and data it touches, the expected use cases. Watch out for offerings that provide no or partial component inventory, or limited visibility into where those AI components originate from.
3. Records risk assessments Create an impact assessment for an AI use case. Link it to a risk scenario in the risk register. A well defined impact assessment linked to one or more use cases and one or more risk scenarios that accounts for threat actor, threat vector, weakness, asset, and impact, tied to the controls that address it. Watch out for offerings that isolate use cases from impact and risk assessments.
4. Puts guardrails in place for protection For this risk, what guardrails can be put in place to mitigate it? A capability for composing rules into guardrails that can either monitor AI activity or actively block it when violations are detected.
5. Turns the program into compliance evidence Show the evidence trail behind one ISO 42001 or EU AI Act requirement A control mapped to the requirement with dated evidence behind it
6. Fits the GRC program you already run How does this share my existing risk register, controls and vendor reviews? An existing risk, control or vendor appears in the AI view without re-entry. Watch out for offerings that run AI governance as a standalone system with its own register and controls.

‍

The criteria, one by one

Evaluate each vendor against each criterion to determine if it fulfills one layer before qualifying for the next.

‍

1. It starts from your objectives and use cases

A governance program exists so you can use AI reliably, securely, and in a way that reduces uncertainty around achieving your objectives while operating with integrity –  not to reduce risk for its own sake. The goal is to do right by your customers, which means protecting them and their data, while delivering value to them and unlocking new levels of productivity within your organization. Therefore, the software you choose should record use cases and tie them to objectives as a first and primary layer of AI governance. 

‍

Take, for example, a development team that adopts AI coding agents to ship code faster. The governance question is about what the agent may touch and change, not about limiting AI outright. 

‍

A vendor demo should open with a use case and the objective behind it. Watch out for red flags, such as tools without native ways to create, track, assign, review, and document approval/rejection decisions about AI use cases. Justin Pagano, Senior Director of GRC Engineering at Vanta, says the same caution applies if “there’s no way to link an AI Use Case to an AI Asset to ensure there’s a clear understanding and inventory of which AI Assets are approved for which AI Use Cases.”

‍

According to the State of Trust Report, 3rd edition, a majority (65%) say their current use of agentic AI already outpaces their understanding of it. Simply increasing the number of alerts won’t add clarity. Instead, use an AI governance checklist to get started. 

‍

{{cta_withimage48="/cta-blocks"}}

‍

2. It builds a real inventory, not a list of agents

You can’t govern what you can’t see. A usable inventory covers agents, the models behind them, the systems and data they can reach, the identities and credentials they use, and the AI tools that teams turn on without telling anyone. The inventory should also link to your compliance data, including your controls, use cases, and impact assessments, so a single AI system is traceable from inventory to evidence. 

‍

An effective inventory connects directly to your use cases. Use cases document the expected state, and inventory shows what’s actually going on. Both are better together because you can then monitor the drift between them.

‍

According to Trust Signals, builder organizations adopt AI vendors at a 73% higher rate. Builder organizations should take special care because this can easily lead to a higher number of risks. Risk management is critical, and an effective inventory can help you stay ahead.

‍

3. It records risk as scenarios, not as missing controls

A risk is a scenario, including who or what (threat actors), exploiting which weaknesses in which assets, with what impact. A missing control is an unmitigated weakness – not a risk. The tool you’re considering therefore needs to be able to capture risks as scenarios and tie controls to them to truly capture common AI risks. 

‍

To understand the difference, consider a team with an agent that has infrastructure credentials. The agent ends up deleting a production database because its permissions were broader than the task required. This scenario of “an agent using infrastructure credentials deletes a production database due to excessive permissions resulting in revenue loss”, is the risk. “No least-privilege access control” is the gap.

‍

When you’re in talks with a vendor, ask them to demonstrate one AI risk scenario end-to-end. If the risk register is a list of failed checks, consider it a red flag. But if the register can hold a scenario, then you can properly prioritize treatment plans around real-world risks.

‍

4. Puts guardrails in place for real-time protection 

Policies alone can’t stop a misconfigured agent or guarantee AI security. Guardrails should stack, including:

‍

  • Rules in the architecture that cannot be bypassed from inside the AI tool
  • The security team's environment monitoring
  • Deterministic rules inside the AI tool, such as lists of commands it may or may not run and checks that fire before an action
  • Probabilistic guardrails, such as managed instruction files (e.g., CLAUDE.md policies) and LLM-as-judge classifiers that review the primary agent's output

‍

If there’s a deterministic deny rule that blocks destructive commands outright, there should also be a review step that catches unusual requests the rule did not anticipate. The review step can automatically capture and alert, giving a person the final decision.

‍

Ask vendors which guardrails exist at which layer, and who decides. Once you’re seeing a demo, ask to see a hard rule, a review step for what the rule misses, and a recorded human decision, all of which are necessary for AI security posture management. Red flags include a system that only has one control type or a system that only provides a policy.

‍

5. It turns the program into compliance evidence

ISO 42001, the EU AI Act and NIST AI RMF become more easily achievable when the four layers above exist. Check that the tool maps controls and evidence to the frameworks you face and produces audit-ready evidence. Where a framework requires impact assessments, check how the tool handles them and at what scope. 

‍

When evaluating vendor options, ask them to show you the evidence trail behind one ISO 42001 or EU AI Act requirement. Similarly, once you’re given a demo, ensure you can easily map a control to the requirement along with the dated evidence behind it. Coverage without evidence is just a checklist.

‍

Vanta, in contrast, continuously monitors security controls. According to the AI Governance Survey, 53% of organizations feel overwhelmed by AI regulations. Choosing the right AI standard, as well as the platform to support it, can help provide clarity in what feels like chaos.

‍

6. It fits the GRC program you already run

You likely already have a risk register, controls, vendor reviews, and prepare for audits–most organizations do. What you likely lack is enough hands. Ask vendors whether the tool extends your program or forces you to adopt a parallel one. 

‍

Your AI inventory should populate and update using the integrations and data already connected to the governance software you’ve chosen. Vanta, for example, can connect AI oversight to your existing controls, mapping AI assessments and agents together. 

‍

Questions to ask AI vendors should include how their software shares existing risk registers, controls, and vendor reviews. Similarly, check whether the vendor’s system has attributes like intended purpose, risk tier, training data provenance, human oversight mechanism, and lifecycle stage. 

‍

“Show me how an AI system is represented as an object — not just a risk entry or a control. Does it have attributes like intended purpose, risk tier, training data provenance, human oversight mechanism, and lifecycle stage?

Faisal Khan, Senior Manager GTM GRC at Vanta

‍

Demonstrations should also show you how the software can map a single AI system to overlapping obligations without duplicating work, and how AI gets inventoried and risk-tiered to support third-party risk management. 

‍

Avoiding duplicated work is critical. According to Trust Signals, GRC personas carry a 44% incomplete task rate, while CISOs sit at 49%. Ultimately, AI isn't changing governance. The same rules apply, but now, teams have to manage a new, ever-evolving risk on top of everything else even as they keep all their previous work going. The risk of incomplete work is only rising. 

‍

How Vanta fits

AI Governance by Vanta helps organizations govern AI as fast as they adopt it. It helps you discover AI across your business, document how it’s used, and connect risks to the policies and controls that guide responsible adoption—all within your existing GRC program. Support for ISO 42001, the EU AI Act, and NIST AI RMF helps you establish accountability and demonstrate responsible AI use while advancing your broader compliance goals.

‍

With its agreement to acquire Pillar Security, Vanta is bringing AI security into that same program. Pillar’s red teaming and runtime protection capabilities will help organizations test AI for vulnerabilities and stop agents from taking unauthorized actions, turning governance policies into real-time protection.

‍

{{cta_simple52="/cta-blocks"}}

Access Review Stage Content / Functionality
Across all stages
  • Easily create and save a new access review at a point in time
  • View detailed audit evidence of historical access reviews
Setup access review procedures
  • Define a global access review procedure that stakeholders can follow, ensuring consistency and mitigation of human error in reviews
  • Set your access review frequency (monthly, quarterly, etc.) and working period/deadlines
Consolidate account access data from systems
  • Integrate systems using dozens of pre-built integrations, or “connectors”. System account and HRIS data is pulled into Vanta.
  • Upcoming integrations include Zoom and Intercom (account access), and Personio (HRIS)
  • Upload access files from non-integrated systems
  • View and select systems in-scope for the review
Review, approve, and deny user access
  • Select the appropriate systems reviewer and due date
  • Get automatic notifications and reminders to systems reviewer of deadlines
  • Automatic flagging of “risky” employee accounts that have been terminated or switched departments
  • Intuitive interface to see all accounts with access, account accept/deny buttons, and notes section
  • Track progress of individual systems access reviews and see accounts that need to be removed or have access modified
  • Bulk sort, filter, and alter accounts based on account roles and employee title
Assign remediation tasks to system owners
  • Built-in remediation workflow for reviewers to request access changes and for admin to view and manage requests
  • Optional task tracker integration to create tickets for any access changes and provide visibility to the status of tickets and remediation
Verify changes to access
  • Focused view of accounts flagged for access changes for easy tracking and management
  • Automated evidence of remediation completion displayed for integrated systems
  • Manual evidence of remediation can be uploaded for non-integrated systems
Report and re-evaluate results
  • Auditor can log into Vanta to see history of all completed access reviews
  • Internals can see status of reviews in progress and also historical review detail
FEATURED VANTA RESOURCE

The ultimate guide to scaling your compliance program

Learn how to scale, manage, and optimize alongside your business goals.